PART XI Practice & Documentation
§34 / 32

Closeout & Commissioning

Cx Levels 1-5 · NETA ATS/MTS · IST · as-builts · O&M

Commissioning is the structured testing that verifies installed systems work as designed. Closeout transfers the facility from contractor to owner with documentation, training, and warranty in place. The bridge from \"design\" to \"operating.\"

Project Phases — Where Closeout + Commissioning Live

PhaseDuration (Atlas DC1)Electrical engineer's role
Schematic Design (SD)2-3 monthsLoads, SLD, room layout, equipment selection
Design Development (DD)3-4 monthsDetailed sizing, coordination, drawings 50% complete
Construction Documents (CD)3-4 monthsIFC drawings + specs (Division 26)
Bid + Award2-3 monthsRFI responses; verify contractor qualifications
Construction Administration (CA)12-18 monthsRFIs, submittals, change orders, site visits, punch lists
Commissioning (Cx)3-6 months (overlaps with end of construction)Witness factory acceptance tests + on-site testing + final acceptance
Closeout1-3 monthsAs-builts, O&M manuals, warranties, training, final invoice
Operations / Warranty1-year warranty periodWarranty walk-through at 11 months

Commissioning — The Full Picture

Commissioning (Cx) is the structured process of verifying that installed systems work as designed. For Atlas DC1, electrical commissioning runs from FAT (Factory Acceptance Test) of major equipment through 5-Level testing to final integrated systems test (IST).

Cx LevelNameWhat's testedWhen
Level 1FAT (Factory Acceptance Test)Each major equipment piece tested at manufacturer's factory before shipmentBefore delivery
Level 2Site Receipt + StorageEquipment received undamaged; stored properlyAt delivery
Level 3Component-Level Static TestInsulation tests, mechanical operation, calibration of individual devices (no power)Pre-energization
Level 4Subsystem Functional TestEach subsystem energized + tested independently (UPS, gen, ATS individually)System energization
Level 5Integrated Systems Test (IST)Full facility tested under simulated failure scenarios — utility loss, gen failure, UPS failure, fault scenariosPre-occupancy / pre-handover

NETA Acceptance Testing

InterNational Electrical Testing Association (NETA) publishes the standard test procedures for electrical equipment. Used at Cx Level 3 (component static testing) by independent electrical testing firms.

NETA standardScope
NETA ATS (Acceptance Testing Specifications)Tests on NEW equipment before energization
NETA MTS (Maintenance Testing Specifications)Tests on EXISTING equipment for periodic maintenance
NETA STD (Standard for Electrical Power Equipment Maintenance)Maintenance frequency + procedures
NETA ETT (Electrical Testing Technician)Certification standards for the testing personnel

What's Tested at Each Cx Level — Atlas DC1 Examples

Level 3 — Component Tests (NETA ATS)

EquipmentNETA tests required
Cables (medium voltage)Insulation resistance + DC withstand (hipot at 80% factory test) + partial discharge if cable > 1000 ft
Cables (low voltage)Insulation resistance only
Transformers (TX-A, TX-B)Insulation resistance + winding ratio (TTR) + DC winding resistance + power factor (Doble) test + oil testing (dielectric breakdown, DGA)
Switchgear (12.47 kV MV SWGR)Operation test (open/close), insulation resistance, contact resistance, primary current injection of CTs, secondary trip testing of relays
Circuit breakersInsulation resistance, contact resistance, time-current calibration (primary current injection)
UPS unitsVendor commissioning (battery acceptance, transfer testing, harmonic verification)
GeneratorsInsulation resistance, governor calibration, voltage regulator setup, 4-hr load bank test, parallel testing if applicable
ATSsManual + automatic transfer cycles, time delay verification, load testing
Grounding systemGround resistance test (3-point fall-of-potential), continuity verification of grounding electrode system
Protective relaysSetting verification + secondary current injection at each pickup level
Surge arrestorsInsulation resistance, leakage current

Level 5 — Integrated System Test (Atlas DC1)

Full facility tested under simulated failure scenarios. Owner/operator + Cx authority + design engineer all witness.

Test scenarioWhat's verifiedPass criteria
Utility loss → genset start (Side A)ATS-A senses loss, signals GEN-A start, gen reaches voltage + frequency, ATS transfersTotal time < 12 sec; UPS rides through; IT load uninterrupted
Utility loss → both sides simultaneouslyBoth ATSs transfer to gens within target timeBoth gens sync with their respective UPS within 15 sec
Genset failure on Side A while runningUPS-A1 detects gen output loss, transitions to battery5-min battery ride-through verified; load shed sequence (CRAH first) initiates
UPS-A1 faultStatic bypass switch activates; load picked up by utility directTransfer < 4 ms (no IT load impact)
480V SWGR-A bus fault87B bus differential trips mainTrip time < 4 cycles (67 ms) measured at oscillograph
Loss of cooling (chiller failure)BMS detects, redundant chiller startsServer inlet temp stays within ASHRAE TC 9.9 envelope
Load bank test at 100% IT designFull IT load (2.5 MW) drawn for 4 hoursAll systems stable; PUE measured + recorded
EPO (Emergency Power Off) testEPO button drops ALL ITE + HVAC per NEC 645.10All loads de-energized within 1 sec

Closeout Deliverables

DeliverableDescriptionWho provides
As-built / record drawingsFinal drawings showing what was actually installed (vs designed)Contractor → Engineer reviews + stamps
O&M manualsOperating + maintenance manuals for every piece of equipmentContractor compiles from manufacturer data
WarrantiesManufacturer warranties (typically 1-2 years on equipment) + contractor workmanship warranty (typically 1 year)Contractor
TrainingOwner staff trained on operating + maintaining systemsContractor + manufacturer reps
Spare parts inventoryCritical spares stocked on-site (relays, fuses, gaskets, capacitors)Contractor purchases per spec
Final inspection sign-offAHJ signs off on final electrical inspection (ready for occupancy)Contractor coordinates with AHJ
Cx reportComprehensive report of all Level 3-5 tests, results, deficiencies + resolutionsCx authority
Final invoice + lien releasesContractor's final billing + waiver of all subcontractor liensContractor
Punch list completion certificationAll construction defects corrected and signed offContractor + Owner walk-through

Worked Example — Atlas DC1 Energization Day

Example · Atlas DC1 spineFirst-time energization sequence — months of prep collapse into one day

Sequence (one week before "first power")

  1. T-7 days: NETA test firm completes all Level 3 component tests. Submits report.
  2. T-5 days: Engineer reviews NETA report; punch list issued to contractor for any deficiencies.
  3. T-3 days: Punch list cleared. Contractor + Cx authority + utility coordinator confirm energization day schedule.
  4. T-1 day: Pre-energization walkthrough. Verify barriers, signage, PPE on hand. EPO buttons functional. AHJ pre-walkthrough.

Energization day timeline

TimeActionWitness
06:00Crew on site; safety briefing; LOTO permits issued
07:00Utility coordinator energizes 12.47 kV primary feeder; verifies voltage at MV switchgearUtility + Engineer + AHJ
07:30Energize TX-A primary; verify secondary voltage at 480V SWGR-A (no load)Engineer + Cx + AHJ
08:00Repeat for TX-B and SWGR-BSame
08:30NEC 230.95(C) GFP performance test on each main breakerAHJ witnesses
09:00Energize ATS-A and ATS-B in normal (utility) positionEngineer + Cx
10:00Energize UPS-A1 in bypass mode; verify input voltage. Then on rectifier; battery comes up to float.Vendor + Engineer
11:00Repeat UPS-A2, UPS-B1, UPS-B2 sequentiallySame
12:00Lunch + first-energization debrief
13:00Energize PDUs + RPPs to no-load voltage. Verify each panel.Engineer + Cx
14:00Energize chiller plant + start CH-1; verify cooling tower operational; chilled water reaches setpointMech engineer + Cx
15:00Atlas DC1 energized + idle. No IT load yet.
15:30Begin Level 5 IST: simulated utility loss → ATS transfers → gen runs → IT load (load bank) ride-through verifiedOwner + Cx + Engineer + Vendor
17:00Run all IST scenarios from Cx test planSame
20:00IST complete. Full day's results documented.
21:00Daily debrief; punch any issues; plan tomorrow's IT load bank ramp testing

"First customer rack" gets installed weeks later after Cx is fully signed off. There's no rush — this day is about verifying the facility CAN power critical IT load. Actual IT load comes when the customer is ready.

If You See THIS, Think THAT

If you see…Think / use…
"Cx" or "commissioning"Structured testing process — Levels 1-5
"FAT" (Factory Acceptance Test)Cx Level 1 — at manufacturer's factory before shipment
"NETA ATS"Independent electrical testing at Cx Level 3
"IST" (Integrated Systems Test)Cx Level 5 — full facility tested under failure scenarios
"Punch list"List of construction deficiencies to be corrected before final acceptance
"As-built drawings" / "Record drawings"Final drawings showing what was actually installed (vs design IFC)
"Substantial completion"Date when facility is fit for intended use; warranty period starts
"Final completion"All punch list resolved; final invoice releasable
"O&M manual"Operating + maintenance manual for installed equipment
"Lien release"Subcontractor waives right to file lien against owner property; required for final payment
"Warranty walkthrough"Inspection at 11 months — final chance to get warranty work done
"EPO test"Emergency Power Off — drops all ITE + HVAC per NEC 645.10. Must be tested at Cx Level 5.
"Hot cutover"Energizing while old system is still live — used in retrofit projects, riskier than greenfield